Following the financial crisis of 2008, the U.S. Congress
rushed in on its white horse to save the day. Its solution: a huge bill
designed to reign in those naughty big banks and Wall Street firms whose greedy
executives created this crisis.
Never mind that Congress tried to fix problems a few times before,
and in doing so contributed substantially to this crisis, and that many of its
current members supported those efforts. Undaunted by previous failures, Congress
yet again created a solution that would prevent this from happening again: the
Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010, better known as
Dodd-Frank, after co-authors Sen. Chris Dodd (D-Conn.) and Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.),
and the new law has made things so much better, right?
“It's in the aggregate, in weighing benefits against costs
and in pondering the unintended consequences, that Dodd-Frank starts to look
like a threat to our financial system.” So wrote Neil Weinberg in American Banker a year ago. “At 2,319
pages, including 250 amendments, and with vastly more rulemaking to come,
Dodd-Frank's costs are only now starting to mount,” he said.
“Whether all this will make our financial system safer is an
open question. Even Barney Frank would likely concede that the hugely expensive
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, of which he is a fan, has not had the intended
effect of wiping out corporate wrongdoing. What's not in dispute is that
Dodd-Frank will impose a major drag on the business of commercial banking and
have numerous knock-off effects that were neither intended nor necessarily
desirable.”
Among those possible unintended consequences: Fewer and
bigger banks, as the cost of compliance forces banks to merge; higher consumer
costs, as banks must pass on their higher regulatory costs to their customers;
and fewer mortgages, as banks flee the mortgage business in reaction to onerous
elements of the law.
A month later co-author Sen. Chris Dodd, who retired after
the law passed the Congress, wrote an op-ed in The Washington Post titled “Five myths about Dodd-Frank,” in which
he defends the law against criticisms, although different criticisms from those
Neil Weinberg discussed. “After a worldwide financial meltdown — and a $700
billion taxpayer-funded bailout — the need for common-sense financial reforms
was clear. But now, even though the Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection
Act of 2010 … is only beginning to take effect, critics are launching false
attacks against the law in an effort to undermine it. Whether they are
intentionally misleading or just misguided, they are wrong about the law’s
purpose and impact.”
Sen. Dodd may not view his work as harmful from his
disconnected and distant perspective, but the people who are directly affected
by it do.
American Bankers Association President Frank Keating, had
this to say about the effects of the law in a letter to Treasury Secretary Timothy
Geithner in June of last year: “While I appreciate that you share our desire
that the law not operate to the harm of community banks, I must report and
emphasize that in actual practice the Dodd-Frank Act is already operating to
the detriment of community banks and promises community banks further harm. … I
have spent the past six months meeting leaders of thousands of these small
banks across the country. There is uniform concern, anxiety, frustration and
anger among these community leaders, who feel betrayed by Washington,” the
letter said.
“Though Congress and administration officials have attempted
to reassure these bankers that Dodd-Frank is not about them – that they are
held harmless by the law – the reality is quite different,” he continued. “True,
the law on paper distinguishes between banks by size. But its $10 billion
threshold – used to “exempt” smaller institutions from provisions in the
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Durbin debit-interchange amendment
– is arbitrary and artificial and is not working.”
A truly dire warning about Dodd-Frank’s likely effects comes
from former Chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Commission (FDIC), Bill
Isaac, who told Larry Kudlow on CNBC’s “The Kudlow Report” in March of this
year that community banks have a lot to fear from the law’s financial reforms.
“The bigger banks can absorb it, the smaller banks can’t,” he said. “I would
not be surprised to see half of the community banks in this country go out of
business if we don’t give some relief from Dodd-Frank for them.”
Community banks are owned and operated by people in their community,
and still possess that local focus and personal touch that larger institutions
usually do not have. They tend to focus on the needs of the communities where
the bank has branches and offices. The people who make lending decisions understand
local needs and are themselves members of the community.
Community banks did not create the problem, but as Bill
Isaac, Neil Weinberg and Frank Keating demonstrate, they are suffering under
the regulations that were supposed to target those who did.
If things at your community bank change for the worse, be
sure to blame the U.S. Congress instead of the bank. Better yet, why not pressure
members of Congress to takes steps to save those valuable local businesses
before it’s too late.







